The more I think about this subject, the more I realize I dont have any desire for "justice" in any form when it comes to murder.
All I really care about is preventing the same person from murdering again. As far as im concerned, a murderer gives up all natural rights to live free amongst everyone else.
Any other crime...... restitution can be made without any kind of prison system. Murder, no. You took away everything someone has or is ever gonna have. You lose all rights.
Prison island for you. Fuck you!!
Since, we are getting deep into this topic.....
I think that one could make an argument against your prison island if it is totally inhumane. In other words, why do they lose ALL rights? I could see losing the right to life, but not the right to be free from torture (unless they tortured and murdered).
What if the old island prisoners literally torture all new comers for years? Things like waterboarding, sodomy, removing limbs, repeated starvation.......
Perhaps, the murderer needs to be made aware of the island before you send them there and they need to
choose to go.
Basically, I don't think that victims' families can do
anything they want to murderers.