I've always hated "Talk Radio's Insurrection"
Who are we supposedly rising up against?
Is this something that is supposed to endear... PD's to us?
Does it endear PD's to us because we are so EXXXXXXTREEEEEME?
It's not incredibly well thought out.
As per the KISS principle (keep it simple stupid) I have to vote for "Talk Radio You Control" because it's simple and explanatory.
Talk Radio's Insurrection is gimmicky and mostly pointless... It would be just as effective as going with the standard "Talk that Rocks"
or "Extreme Hot Talk Radio" or "Radio Rebellion"
I also definitely would not support the trend of moving away from being the talk show that anyone can call in about whatever they want, to becoming a more politically driven, standard, typical talk show.
If anything, the only tag lines I would support, would be if someone came up with a catchier way of saying "Talk Radio you control" in an alliterative fashion... Having the principle of the show as the tag line is something I see as very important.
hehe... You could combine the two... "Talk Radio You Control" and "Talk Radio's Insurrection"
and say "Talk Radio, out of control"
Talk Radio that won't be controlled... MAAAAAAAAN.