God is a gap concept. We do not know how something works or what it is so we assign god to it. Then, we do not know why some things happen to us so to hopefully enable emotional stability we invent a god.
I'm not arguing that religion isn't a fiction, I'm arguing that it has its place in the culture we're all a part of. Human civilization is a chicken-and-an-egg paradox, and it's an objective historical fact that religious faith filled the gap, allowing social order to be enforced before it could be scientifically understood - and it's not really understood to this day.
Huh? When did you ever say anything coherent on this issue? I've written bits about religious functionalism in my emerging philosophy of "evolutionary pragmatism" for a long time now...
"God is a concept, by which we measure our pain." |
I like that idea, since for many atheists the concept of God suddenly resurfaces when they're experiencing a heart attack, or something similar, and for some hypochondriac atheists the slightest panic can lead to "oh God, oh God, oh God", even if it's not out loud, as it most often isn't - that feeling of complete and total helplessness and the impossibility of reason in light of mortal terror. Well, whatever that concept was when you were having a heart attack, "real" or not, still exists when your heart is beating normally.
By that measure, it won't be too long before the Da Vinci code is accepted truth. Wait, I bet Harry Potter will become the new bible within my lifetime. Sorry, no more time to chat. I have to pack for my pilgrimage to Hogwarts. |
The mind-share of those books is minuscule compared to the major religions, and taken far less seriously, and is guaranteed to pass soon enough. In evolutionary pragmatism, the competitive advantage of a trait validates its desirability: we have two arms and two legs because that design has stood the test of time. Pragmatic thinking can lead people to make themselves aware of those much smaller and weaker cultural trends that you've mentioned, like if you're trying to impress your would-be mother-in-law and she's a zealous Dan Brown fanatic, but the relevance of religion remains tremendous. Secular cultures haven't even learned to breed sustainably yet!