I recently caught the end of the "What to do with Ben Tucker" thread where apparently the topic has shifted to "Does Anime Suck?"
Out of Respeck for Ghandi I am making this poll so that thread can go back on topic, and we can discuss the burning issue of the suckitude of Anime (or the lack there of).
My opinion is, like with any other art form, that sometimes Anime' sucks, sometimes it is great, and sometimes its just ok.
Claiming that an entire style of art as diverse as Anime sucks just because you have had a bad experience or two with it is illogical.
That is the equivalent to saying that all books suck just because you have read a couple of bad ones.
There many different types of movies and TV shows that carry the label "Anime".
Yea, there are conventions, and some of them seem weird to us Americans, but American cartoons have their own types of conventions that we don't notice because they are a part of our culture or they have been a part of American cartoons since the beginning.
I hate it when people dismiss "Comic Books" and "Cartoons" as being just for kids. Comics have not been "just for kids" in this country at least since
Will Eisner. Some of the best works of art in the last century were comics and graphic novels. 'Cartoons' have not been a "kid only" medium in this country since at least 1972's
"Fritz the Cat" by Bakshi.
In Japan, Comics (Manga) and Cartoons (Anime) are treated as true art forms. There are manga and anime that are produced for 80 year old men, 45 year old women and 5 year old kids. They don't have these hang-ups that we do because they have been exposed to them their whole life.
Look at "The Simpsons" it was the first 'cartoon' that I noticed adults admit that they watched. And now 17 years later, we also have "South Park", "Drawn Together" "Family Guy" "Futurama" and "King of the Hill". People are
starting to realize that 'cartoons' aren't just for kids. But they still think of Anime as Pokemon and Speed Racer.
Granted, a lot of the Anime that American see does suck. Why? Because despite all of the great "Adult Cartoons" that have been produced, most Americans still think of Cartoons as childish or 'for kids', so there is not much of a market among adults in this country for quality animation and good stories. As a result, a lot of the Anime that you see over here was produced for Japanese children and are aimed at our children.
If people were not so dismissive of this wonderful art form, they would get to experience some truly great works of art.
Anyone who still thinks that Cartoons and Comics are childish, should check out
Scott McCloud's groundbreaking work
"Understanding Comics".
BRAVO!! Your Understanding Comics is a landmark dissection and intellectual consideration of comics as a valid medium. Its employment of comic art as its vehicle is brilliant. Everyone...anyone interested in this literary form must read it. Every school teacher should have one.