Worst Star Wars Movie

I - The Phantom Menace

17 (40.5%)

II - Attack of the Clones

10 (23.8%)

III - Revenge of the Sith

10 (23.8%)

IV - A New Hope

2 (4.8%)

V - The Empire Strikes Back

0 (0%)

VI - Return of the Jedi

3 (7.1%)

Total Members Voted: 17

[Turd Ferguson]

But then I remembered how incredibly annoying Hayden Christensen is, and how every scene with him in it-- especially any "courting" scenes between him and Natalie Portman-- seemed about five hours long.

Hayden Christensen was horribly annoying.  However, JarJar was worse, in my mind.  Maybe I was too hard on the muppets.  It's hard for me to say which is worse.

Elements of "really bad" include:

• JarJar Binks
• Muppets
• Pod Racing and all related Muppetry-like CGI
• Hayden Christensen
• Ewoks
• C3PO, at times

Sum it up, and the cute and whiney have to go.  Frankly, I wasn't a big fan of Natalie Portman's role either.  I don't fault her; I fault the role.  Oh, and the kid who played Anakin in Episode I sucked too.  Ewan McGregor and Liam Neeson made the first one watchable.

Wat?? Me cant believe you not like the Jar-Jar. That think make Jar-Jar saaaaaad. Me try talking like Rasta-Man all time and being cutesy funny and you not likes it? I be very funny in other movie sometime............. you see. Jar-Jar show you I am good. Me be famous and and snort coke off hooker stomach and be on top of world again. Then Jar-Jar get last laugh forever.

[MacFall]

[sillyperson]

I wasn't a big fan of Natalie Portman's role either.  I don't fault her; I fault the role.  Oh, and the kid who played Anakin in Episode I sucked too.  Ewan McGregor and Liam Neeson made the first one watchable.

This, this, this, and these two.