Sure -- unless they're providing $5 worth of goods and change in exchage for $2.78 worth of silver.
When you give them FRN's they get $0 worth of silver. They get a piece of paper that says $5 on it. They get that with the liberty dollar too. The silver is a bonus.
Sure - this is absolutely correct. However, the problem with the
Liberty Dollar in particular is that when you pass a $5 Liberty quarter in exchange for goods or services that have been valued by the seller at $5 in Federal Reserve Notes, you've passed on the premium of the purchase of that silver to that seller and have taken goods and services from him at a price less than what he has valued them at.
It doesn't matter what you feel money should be backed by -- all that matters is what the seller has valued his products and services at. If he has valued his product or service at $5, and he accepts an amount of silver that can only be exchanged for half the value of his product or service, he's either an idiot or a really nice guy who doesn't mind selling products and services for less than what he wants to get for them.Â
Sure, you can say that $5 worth of Liberty Dollars is worth 1/4 ounce of silver and $5 of FRNs is worth zero silver -- that's absolutely true; except that what is frequently forgotten and overlooked is that FRNs are
indeed backed by a precious commodity that is much more valuable to most Americans than silver - their time, labor, and personal property. $5 in FRNs is redeemable for nine minutes of time and labor. That means that nine minutes of my time and labor is redeemable for two packs of Marlboros. Six hours of my time is redeemable for an Apple iPod. That time and labor is represented by FRNs.Â
Therefore, it doesn't matter if the Liberty Dollar is backed by silver. If I expend my time and energy in exchange for Liberty Dollars instead of FRNs, I have to work 18 minutes for two packs of cigarettes and I have to work overtime to buy my iPod.
No thanks.Â
Now -- if you want to give me
three $5 Liberty Quarters for nine minutes of my time, that's fine. I'm in the business of making money that I can buy other products and services with from other people who also know that FRNs are backed by their time and labor. I'm not there as a seller of products, services, or time, to help you recoup the money you lost buying silver from NORFED at two times market value that I can't trade for face value unless I join NORFED's pyramid.